# Shortest Formula Challenge #6: Results and Discussion Reply

A couple of weeks ago I set readers the challenge which can be found here.

Once again, some truly excellent responses and a noticeably collaborative attempt towards obtaining our final, minimal-length solution. So many thanks to all who contributed: Alex, John Jairo, Lori, Snakehips and Will!

And that solution, at 108 characters, is:

`=LOOKUP(,0/FREQUENCY(0,2^-(LEN(Q5:Q77)>4)/MMULT(SUMIF(U3:U28,MID(Q5:Q77,COLUMN(A1:G1),1),V3),1^V3:V9)),Q5:Q6)`

How does it work?

# Simultaneous Locating of First and Last Numbers in a String 23

I was initially debating whether to give this post a more pragmatic title, such as “Extracting Phone Numbers from a String”, that being one of the more common practical applications for the techniques outlined here.

However, the extraction of phone numbers (I’m referring here to that type which employs some form of delimiter, e.g. 1-800-12345, and not that which comprises a non-delimited numerical string, e.g. 180012345, there existing already well-documented formula techniques for the extraction of the latter – although of course the set-up given here will work for those as well) is certainly not the only use for this method, and so, in the end, I chose to go with a less restrictive, more theoretical title.

# Return Entry Corresponding to Maximum Value Based on Conditions 55

We are often faced with the practical situation in which we need to return the entry from a certain column which corresponds to the maximum numerical value from another column subject to one or more conditions.

For example, from the table below:

we may wish to return the date (column C) which corresponds to the latest version (column B) for a given order number (column A), where by “latest” we mean “largest numerically”.

# Sorting a List Alphabetically (Without Filters) 17

In this post I would like to present a formula-based solution which returns an alphabetically-sorted list of the entries from a given range. Effectively, then, the formula gives equivalent results to those obtained using the in-built sort feature (though which, for whatever reasons, we may not be in a position to use).

For example, given the unsorted list in A2:A11 as below, we will return the ordered results as given in B2:B11.

# Extracting numbers from a string 2: Consecutive numbers at end 3

This is the second in a series of discussions on the techniques available for extracting numbers from an alphanumeric string. In the first instalment in this series (which can be found here) I looked at extracting consecutive numbers which appear at the start of the string, e.g. 123ABC456.

In this post I will concentrate on techniques for extracting numbers from a string where:

• The numbers are consecutive
• The consecutive string of numbers is found at the very end of the string
• The desired result is to have those consecutive numbers returned to a single cell

As previously, for each of the given solutions, we need to test its soundness in two separate cases: firstly, where there are no numbers elsewhere in the string, e.g. ABC456 and secondly, where there are some numbers elsewhere in the string, either at the start, e.g. 123ABC456, or in the middle, e.g. ABC123DEF456.

# Extracting numbers from a string 1: Consecutive numbers at start 8

This is the first in a series of discussions on the techniques available for extracting numbers from an alphanumeric string. Since we often have many different solutions at our disposable for such tasks, I will attempt to present what I feel are the principal candidates and, for each of these set-ups, discuss the merits and potential drawbacks inherent in each.

In the next instalment in this series I shall look at extracting consecutive numbers which appear at the end of the string, e.g. ABC123. In later posts I will deal with cases in which the desired numbers to be extracted are interspersed within the string in groups of one or more, e.g. ABC12DE345-FG6H789, in which case we may be interested in extracting either the number 123456789 into a single cell or each of 12, 345, 6 and 789 into four separate cells.

I shall also consider in future posts cases in which there may be several numbers within a string, though from which we wish to extract perhaps only one (or more) of these numbers, and for which our choice of extraction is based upon one or more criteria. For example, given a string of the form X12-X34-X56-X78-X90 we may wish to develop a technique which extracts the number immediately preceding the fourth occurrence of a hyphen within that string.